“Back to Black” is directed by Sam Taylor-Johnson (A Million Little Pieces, Fifty Shades of Grey) and stars Marisa Abela (Industry, She is Love), Jack O’Connell (Unbroken, Money Monster), Eddie Marsen (Ray Donovan, Atomic Blonde), and Lesley Manville (Maleficent, Phantom Thread) in a musical biopic chronicling a large segment of the life of Amy Winehouse and her journey to creating one of the most successful albums of the 21st century.

While they may not be my goto genre, musical biopics are often a type of movie that manages to garner my attention when it comes out. Not only do they tell stories about famed artists people have come to know and love like Elton John in “Rocketman” or Freddie Mercury in “Bohemian Rhapsody,” but those movies often get a lot of attention around awards season. In addition to these actors getting attention during shows like the BAFTAs or the Oscars, if you have ever checked out the 1st or 5th Annual Jack Awards, you would know that some of the acting awards went to lead roles in biopics based on a musician’s real life. One of my favorite lead performances that comes to mind in all the movies I have seen is Jamie Foxx as Ray Charles in the 2004 movie “Ray.” While Foxx’s singing in the movie is limited, he did all of his piano playing. Not to mention, there is a certain physicality to his performance. Same goes for Rami Malek in “Bohemian Rhapsody.” Much like Foxx as Ray Charles, Malek did not do all of his own singing as Freddie Mercury. But looking back at some of the real Live Aid concert and the one they make for the movie, it is insane how close of a resemblance Malek is to Mercury himself in terms of physicality. If I have to be real, “Bohemian Rhapsody” was above average, but Malek’s performance carries the film.

Similarly, that is how I feel about “Back to Black.” Do I think the story is good? Yes. Do I like all the characters? I would say so. I think everyone in the movie has their moment. But what sells this movie for me from start to finish is Marisa Abela as Amy Winehouse.

One of the best compliments I can give an actor, is that I cannot imagine anybody else in their role. And when it comes to Marisa Abela as Amy Winehouse, that thought came across my mind a couple times. Maybe Jenna Ortega could play the role just because she has a certain look to her that personally sells me. But when this movie was shot, she was not even of legal drinking age in the U.S.. That said, I am fairly happy with what we got here. To be real though, it is not my favorite lead performance in a biopic. There is not as much of an oomph factor here to the performance that I have seen from say Austin Butler as Elvis Presley. Some of Abela’s performance feels played up and almost in the realm of fantasy, but there are also a fair share of grounded moments to balance out those exaggerated ones. The performance is not perfect, but there is a lot of good to it.

I also really liked the movie’s attempt to show the chemistry between Winehouse and her love interest, Blake Fielder-Civil, played finely by Jack O’Connell. If anything, I thought the scenes between these two were some of the best parts of the movie and I honestly wouldn’t mind seeing these actors on screen again in another project.

One of the things I will remember most about “Back to Black” is that from start to finish, there was always this consistent tone to the movie, and it seemed to match the tone that comes to mind when I think or talk about Amy Winehouse herself. I do not listen to her music. Frankly, I do not care for her music. Having seen this movie, I do not think I am going to go back and listen to her music. But as I watched the movie, even in its lighter moments, there was always this bittersweet nature to it. If you were to ask me to talk about Amy Winehouse, I will probably say what a lot of other people say and note that her life was taken too soon. We likely missed out on someone who could have built a humungous legacy. Similarly, as I watched this movie, there seems to be this lingering gloom. Granted, there are several moments where that feeling is minute, but it is still there. I must also add the movie’s greyish and bleak color grading, which is practically noticeable in almost every scene, may have an effect on said gloom as well.

When it comes to these musical biopics, I often seek these movies out with my mom. These are some of her gotos. This one is no exception. When she walks out of these films, she often talks about how much she liked hearing the artist’s music as shown in the final product. Knowing the title of this film, we get to hear a good portion of Winehouse’s discography. My favorite of the songs brought to life would be “Rehab.” Again, much of this movie is about not just Amy Winehouse’s rise as an artist, but it also dives into her personal life, and her struggles with drugs and alcohol. This song, not to mention its performance in particular, connects the movie’s ideas together beautifully. The scene in the film is beautifully timed, edited, and as highlighted already, portrayed by Marisa Abela herself.

If I have any real negatives with “Back to Black,” I would say there are parts of the film that are more memorable than others. I would not be able to tell you the name of every character that is in the movie, perhaps some minor details that are in the movie, or every song that is in the movie. Then again, I already mentioned I am not the biggest Amy Winehouse fan. The movie itself, while it is really good, does not have many moments where I am going to look back and label it iconic, or some similar degree that would indicate prestige. As a biopic, this is a decent look into Amy Winehouse’s life with a good amount of tonal consistency. And even though I will say the movie does have an everlasting glimmer of gloom throughout, the gloom never gets to a point where I feel truly heartbroken as a viewer. There are tragic, unfortunate things happening throughout this movie. Sadly, I don’t think I am feeling the melancholy this movie wants me to feel at times. It’s not like when I watched “Priscilla” and was unspeakably riveted by Cailee Spaeny as Priscilla Presley. Here’s an analogy my fellow “Django Unchained” fans would understand, “Back to Black” had my curiosity, but when it comes to keeping my eyes and ears glued, “Priscilla” had my attention, if that makes any sense. “Back to Black” is not going to end up in my top films of the year. If anything, it will wind up somewhere in the middle. But there are plenty of pros to this film that could potentially make a one time watch justified should you decide to check it out.

In the end, “Back to Black” is engaging, but there is not much to it that truly individualizes it. It feels wrong to call a movie like this ordinary, even though you can say it has some familiar beats from other titles of its kind. “Back to Black” has neat production value, good acting, and a fine pace to it that rarely had me disinterested. It’s good, but not great. Now if you are an Amy Winehouse fan, it is hard for me to say whether or not I recommend this film, partially because, again, I do not listen to her music. For the record, going back to Abela’s performance, she does all of her own singing. From a straight up commitment perspective, I admire Abela’s efforts here. As for whether her singing translates well for the average Amy Winehouse fan, that is for them to decide. I must also note that I was 11 when Winehouse died. I was not as in touch with trends, culture, and goings on at the time as I am now. But as a pure movie and story, it gets a thumbs up from me. Not a strong one, but a thumbs up nevertheless. I am going to give “Back to Black” a 6/10.

“Back to Black” is now playing in select theaters and is available to rent or buy on VOD.

Thanks for reading this review! My next review is going to be for the new comedy “Summer Camp.” Stay tuned! Also coming soon, I will be sharing my thoughts on “Young Woman and the Sea,” “Inside Out 2,” “Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga,” and “Thelma.” If you want to see these reviews and more from Scene Before, follow the blog either with an email or WordPress account! Also, check out the official Facebook page! I want to know, did you see “Back to Black?” What did you think about it? Or, who is someone whose life you feel was taken too soon that you would have like to have seen live longer? For me, Chadwick Boseman. Between his time in the MCU, an Oscar nomination, and his ability to put on killer performances, I would like to see what other projects he would have done had he not passed in August 2020. Let me know down below! Scene Before is your click to the flicks!