Clayface (2026): Part Body Horror, Part Revenge Thriller, All Entertaining

Courtesy of Warner Bros. – © Warner Bros.

“Clayface” is directed by James Watkins (Eden Lake, Speak No Evil) and stars Tom Rhys Harries (White Lines, Suspicion), Naomi Ackie (I Love Boosters, Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker), David Dencik (Serena, Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy), Max Minghella (Spiral, The Handmaid’s Tale), and Eddie Marsan (Happy-Go-Lucky, The World’s End). This is the third film in the Detective Comics Universe and is about star actor Matt Hagen who becomes disfigured by a mobster, motivating him to undergo a scientific procedure to restore his appearance. However, the procedure goes wrong, turning Hagen into a creepy monster who seeks revenge.

About a decade ago, the comic book movie sub-genre was creme of the crop. Whether we are talking quality or box office. The Marvel Cinematic Universe in particular had hit after hit after hit after hit. This even includes the Tom Holland-starring “Spider-Man” films, which wound up being collaborations between the Disney-owned Marvel Studios and Sony Pictures.

Around the same time, Sony thought of ways to make use of Spider-Man characters without necessarily making Peter Parker or the MCU the center of attention. The “Spider-Verse” movies have been particularly phenomenal and I cannot wait to see what they do with a third installment when it comes out. Another direction they took was to make live-action films based on Spider-Man villains. The “Venom” movies in particular made a bit of money, but that character was by far the biggest hit Sony had with this run. I say that as someone who particularly did not enjoy two out of three “Venom” movies, but I know they have fans and those fans definitely showed up at the box office, even during the second movie as theaters continued their recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic.

I say this because “Clayface,” which is based on a DC character, not Marvel, feels like a superior version of those movies. This is not to say that “Clayface” is Shakespeare. But if you are a DC fan, chances are you might be satisfied. If you are a horror movie fan, chances are you might be satisfied. If you are looking for a quick, decent watch, chances are you might be satisfied. I do not know if this film is going to be for everyone. This is the third film in the DCU. Unlike the last two, not only does it center on a less than heroic character, but there is a massive genre shift from the previous movies. I would also avoid recommending this movie for younger audiences. The film is rated R, and for good reason.

The Sony Spider-Man Universe movies and “Clayface” have their differences. I think these differences are what make “Clayface” watchable for me. This film is a bit more grounded than say “Venom,” which yes, also sees its main character turn into something of a monster, but whereas that film sort of treats Eddie Brock as an anti-hero, “Clayface” sees its main character, Matt Hagen, as something of a bad guy. From that alone, pulling off a movie like “Clayface” is somewhat difficult because it becomes harder to root for the main character. At least on paper. However, the movie’s execution of his journey, puts that fear to the side.

For one thing, Tom Rhys Harries is a great choice to play the lead. This is not my first time seeing Harries on screen. I watched him in “The Gentlemen” years ago, but I am not going to pretend I remember him from the movie. Heck, I barely remember the movie in general. I did not think it was that great. “Clayface” marks the first time that I got to truly soak in Harries’ talents. I would love to see more roles from him down the line and I think this film is a proper showcase of what he is capable of. Granted, he is given material that is not only fun to watch, but I imagine for an actor, is a hoot to see come to life. Every actor dreams about those milestone moments in their career from the big break to awards recognition. In this film, the character of Matt Hagen is on top of the world. He has a successful line of work. The film sees him being nominated for an Oscar. While “Clayface” may not be an Oscar-worthy film, it is neat to see the joy Harries experiences early on in the film. It is a good setup for what is to come.

Though just because “Clayface” is not Oscar-worthy does not mean you should avoid it. Actually, quite the opposite. This film at times has the same B-movie feel that Sony and Marvel’s “Venom” gave years ago. Although “Clayface” feels like it has an artistic touch, whereas “Venom” at times gave the illusion that it came off an assembly line. DC Studios is taking a much different approach with its characters than some other comic book movie universes, including the preceding Detective Comics Extended Universe. Sure, the DCEU had “Suicide Squad” in 2016, which centered around various criminals or villains like Killer Croc and Harley Quinn, but the story put them in a situation where they played a more heroic role. They were put in a position where they had to “do the right thing.” Granted, everyone is the hero of their own story. Therefore, even someone with bad morals believes they are doing the right thing, even if most people would argue it is for the wrong reason. But whereas “Suicide Squad” saw indecent people fighting for the greater good, “Clayface” sees its main character taking on people for more personal reasons.

This is one of the reasons why I would say unlike “Superman,” “Clayface” is not a film for every audience. One could argue that no film in history is for everyone, but “Clayface” is an R-rated body horror film. Heck, I am friends with someone who uses their AMC A-List stubs to the same degree that a “Mario Kart” player way behind in the pack will use a blue shell. And that is just about any chance they get. Despite this, the person told me they are avoiding this movie because it is in their words “too horror.” For the record, having seen the movie, I never found anything in it to be revoltingly scary or nightmare-inducing. Though I can see several audiences walking out of this film at least somewhat creeped out by it. When I say this film is not the scariest I have ever watched. I do not mean this as a dig. It is definitely creepy, but it is not like there is one particular scene that made me jump out of my skin. “Clayface” is a film that successfully combines different genres and ideas. It is part body horror, part revenge action thriller, part character study. It handles these concepts rather well.

The movie is also very nice-looking. While it may not look as expensive as “Superman,” “Clayface” does make the most of its reported $44 million budget. Despite the movie being a bit dark, it has some colorful and neon-filled scenes. The lighting is pristine and very much sets the mood. I know I said this film is not Oscar-worthy, but I will not deny that the makeup specifically could pick up a nomination. The makeup effects, particularly on Harries’ character as we see him evolve, easily caught my attention.

Another thing that caught my attention is the film’s aspect ratio. The film is in 2.76:1, or Ultra Panavision. It is such an unusual choice to have an aspect ratio like that for any movie coming out nowadays. In fact, director Watkins says the reason he wanted to have the aspect ratio is to make the movie look epic and old-school. I can definitely tell that is what Watkins was trying to go for. Heck, I thought “Sinners” was one of the most epic movies released last year and that used Ultra Panavision quite well. I cannot confirm or deny whether that film inspired Watkins to shoot “Clayface” the way he did, but I would not be surprised if that is the case. After all, the film was shot months after “Sinners” came out, when it was still a hot topic. Although to be completely real, even if Watkins wants to sell me on such an adjective, “epic” is not the first word I would use to describe “Clayface,” especially when the previous two movies in the DCU feature powerful characters who fly and deal with matters on multiple planets. This is not to say that “Clayface” is not interesting or fun. But epic feels bit exaggerative. On that note, I think a taller aspect ratio would have arguably been more fitting because it would it add to the film’s overall feeling of discomfort. That’s just me.

When I do these comic book movie reviews, I often like to take a look at where exactly the cinematic universe would go from this point. Sadly, due to recent events including James Gunn and Peter Safran stepping down as the heads of DC Studios, and Jeremy Latcham taking their place, the roadmap is a bit unclear as of now. Though prior to this happening, I cannot imagine most audiences would have guessed that the third movie set in this cinematic universe would have focused on Clayface. Heck, this is a Batman villain, and yet, we have still not gotten a Batman movie. Sure, technically, Batman has already appeared in the DCU to a certain extent with HBO Max’s “Creature Commandos” series, but that is about all the universe has given us. Personally, I am at the point where I do not care what comic book character you focus on first in your universe. Maybe you should start with a “big gun” like Superman to draw the audience in, but after that, you have permission to go crazy. This is especially true if James Gunn and Peter Safran were to actually stay. However, this month proves that we can never have nice things.

When Gunn was involved with the DCEU, he worked on “The Suicide Squad” and “Peacemaker.” The former is still my favorite DC movie and the latter is action-packed and hilarious. Sticking with the former, that film saw Gunn bringing unlikely characters to the forefront like King Shark and Polka Dot Man. So, if Gunn and Safran were cool with bringing someone like Clayface to fruition early on, I am for it. My rule is make a good movie first. It does not matter who appears in that movie. It is more of a matter of what you do with the idea or characters that movie centers around. Am I concerned about what these movies are building up to at this point? Not necessarily, though it is nice to imagine what this universe’s version of a Justice League could resemble. For now, I am just enjoying the ride.

The movie is not entirely perfect. Even though the film does have a different flair and direction for a comic book based-film, it does feel somewhat predictable in certain ways. This is not to say that such predictable moments were bad. But as the movie progressed, the roadmap was somewhat clear as to where the character of Matt Hagen would take himself. Having watched a number of comic book movies and origin stories through said subgenre, there is often a formula to these stories that becomes repetitive with each go. The formula can work, but there are a lot of origin stories that tend to borrow elements from others to the point where I end up thinking, “Oh, I have seen this happen in that movie,” multiple times during the same experience. What really separates “Clayface” from many of the other origin stories of this kind that have been brought to the screen is that this one does not necessarily focus on someone who becomes a hero. Matt Hagen wants revenge. Sure, if you look at a movie like 2002’s “Spider-Man,” Peter Parker wanted to get revenge and take down the person who killed Uncle Ben, but as the movie progresses, we see Peter remember his uncle’s teachings and philosophies, making him the hero everyone looks up to. Hagen is in a position where he feels like he has reached his lowest low, and now he feels the need to fight back to the top.

The film runs for an hour and 48 minutes. For the first half, the film is by no means boring, but it often feels like it is taking some time just to get going. The more action-packed material happens in the second half, which is to be expected, but at times I felt like I was barely pacing through the first half just to get to that action-packed latter portion. The film is nevertheless entertaining in each scene, even if some clearly stand out better than others. Despite the film’s flaws, there is still enough to write home about with “Clayface.”

In the end, “Clayface” is a lot of fun. This is the third DCU movie, and again, with James Gunn and Peter Safran leaving, I have no idea where things are going to go, but if they were to stay, I would tell them that if we can keep getting movies as enjoyable as this, then this universe is going in the right direction. It is much-needed win for the DCU at this point, at least on the movie front. I have heard decent things on the TV side with “Lanterns,” but I have not had time to check it out. But movie-wise, this is significantly better than “Supergirl,” which is almost the worst movie I have seen this year. That film, which was directed by Craig Gillespie, felt like it was helmed by someone doing a bad James Gunn impression. Gunn has some experience with horror. I recommend watching “Slither” if you have the chance. But this feels more like an artist doing a story with their own touch rather than seeing someone emulate another person. The film is predictable and takes a little while to get to the nitty gritty, but I give it a thumbs up. I am going to give “Clayface” a 7/10.

“Clayface” is now playing in theaters. Tickets are available now.

Thanks for reading this review! If you have a moment, please be so kind as to do me some favors! Check out the latest episode of Scene Before’s original web series, Movie Requests! The series features yours truly talking about movies suggested by your favorite stars. This latest episode features comedian Adam Conover! You may have seen him on television through programs including “Adam Ruins Everything,” “The Crystal Maze,” and “The G Word with Adam Conover.” Also, another favor I would like to ask of you is to subscribe to my YouTube channel and hit the notification bell that way you can stay up to date on more Movie Requests episodes as they drop!

We are getting close to the finale, and trust me, you will not want to miss it… Only two episodes left! Enjoy them while they last… Unless I decide to do a second season, which… We’ll see.

My next review is going to be for “You Can See Everything.” Stay tuned! Also coming soon, I will be sharing my thoughts on “Wild Horse Nine,” “La Bola Negra,” “The Cat in the Hat,” and “I Play Rocky.” If you want to see these reviews and more from Scene Before, follow the blog either with an email or WordPress account! Also, check out the official Facebook page! I want to know, did you see “Clayface?” What did you think about it? Or, do you think we will get a Batman movie in this exact cinematic universe at some point? We already got one of his villains, so where is Batman? That is probably going to be a lingering question for some time. Leave your thoughts down below! Scene Before is your click to the flicks!

Superman (2025): The DC Universe Begins with a Big Bang

“Superman” is directed by James Gunn (Guardians of the Galaxy, The Suicide Squad) and stars David Corenswet (Twisters, Pearl), Rachel Brosnahan (The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, House of Cards), Nicholas Hoult (The Menu, Juror #2), Edi Gathegi (Into the Badlands, Twilight), Anthony Carrigan (The Forgotten, Gotham), Nathan Fillion (The Rookie, Firefly), and Isabella Merced (Transformers: The Last Knight, Dora and the Lost City of Gold). This film centers around the titular hero as he takes on Lex Luthor while trying to win back the general public’s trust.

It’s finally here. A brand spankin’ new cinematic universe. Just like DC’s last attempt at one of these ongoing sagas, we are kicking things off with Superman, this time around played by David Corenswet. When the DC Universe was announced, I was excited about it. Yes, I was enjoying the DCEU, but demand for it to continue has clearly diminished with one unsuccessful project after another, so I get why this new universe is happening. What really sold me is who would be involved. There was Peter Safran, a producer behind many of Warner Bros.’ recent films, including some DC fare. And alongside him on the more creative side was James Gunn, the director of this very film.

While Gunn is not my favorite filmmaker working today, he has a respectable knack for the craft. I thought he was perfect to shepherd something like this partially because of his love for comic books, as well as his experience with adapting them into films like Marvel’s “Guardians of the Galaxy.” Plus, with the release of “The Suicide Squad” in 2021, he is responsible for making my favorite DC movie ever. And I say this as someone who has seen every DCEU movie. Every Christopher Reeve “Superman” movie.” Every Christopher Nolan “Batman” movie. Even “The LEGO Batman Movie.” Not to mention “V for Vendetta!” There was a point where “Superman” was my most anticipated film of the year. That has changed having seen the more recent marketing, which was not horrible, but kind of lost steam for me the more I knew about the film. There were undoubtedly plenty of creative marketing stunts in recent weeks, but if we are just talking about trailers, that is where I feel the batting average starts to weaken. But who knows? Maybe I could walk out of the movie having a blast.

A lot was riding on this film between a new cinematic universe, trying to get general audiences onboard, as well as making a relatable story about a god. James Gunn and Peter Safran can take a moment to breathe a sigh of relief. This film is excellent.

Is “Superman” my favorite comic book film of the year? No. I prefer “Thunderbolts*” over “Superman,” but there is no denying that the latter is a blast. That said, there is something that separates “Superman” from a lot of recent comic book movies, even some of the better ones. With this being a brand new cinematic universe, there is no homework to be done to prepare for this movie. “Superman” is not the first entry to the DC Universe. It is the first film installment, but the current cinematic universe started earlier this year on HBO Max with the animated series “Creature Commandos.” Even so, one can go into “Superman” knowing nothing about the DC Universe, the comics, or any other piece of media related to the character and have a good time. It likely helps if you are more attached to that stuff, but it is not necessary.

While “Superman” may not be my favorite comic book film of the year, there is a serious possibility that this is likely the best “Superman” movie ever. It is definitely a more generalized interpretation of the character than “Man of Steel” but it is more pleasing to the palate. Despite my praise for “Man of Steel” and what would be my favorite “Superman” film if it were not for this latest one coming out, “Superman: The Movie,” there are parts of both stories that drag. Meanwhile, in this film, the pacing is quite literally perfect. The film is not exactly an origin story, though it does introduce Superman’s birthparents as well as Ma and Pa Kent. Instead it starts off with Superman losing a battle for the first time. We are not even two minutes into the movie, and it has already made a literal god compelling and relatable with what may be his lowest low as a hero. And it does not even stop there. Because if you stick around for the rest of the film, Superman has to deal with issues that are not only relevant, but incredibly human.

“Superman” astoundingly links to multiple prominent real world issues. Whether it has to do nations or groups of people fighting each other, hostile world leaders, the downsides of social media, or having your life forever changed by false information. The film is also likely an allegory on immigration. After all, Superman is not from Earth. So, despite him living there, he is technically an illegal alien. The rivalry between Superman and Lex Luthor sees the latter irritated by the former because in a sense he, an outsider, is being prominently celebrated to the point where Lex, an Earthling, envies him. This film does an amazing job of putting pressures on a popular figure like Superman. He knows how to be a hero in a general sense, but he is not as super in other areas such as dealing with social media controversy or handling the press. Although I will say, as well as that last concept is, it is a tad unexpected considering Clark Kent works for a news outlet, but still.

When I think about “Superman” my mind often goes to about how hard the character must be to write, and this film does an amazing job in terms of its script. I was genuinely surprised by how hooked I was by James Gunn’s vision from start to finish. But the pressure must have been equally as high for David Corenswet. Some of you who have not seen this movie yet are probably wondering who Corenswet is, but if you watch the film, I think he would be responsible for putting a smile on your face. When it comes to the movie variants of Supes, I do not think a single performer has ever been bad. That said, as much respect as I have for Henry Cavill as Superman in the DCEU, I think Corenswet’s character channels more joy, and he works well that way. Part of this is due to how he was written and directed, but when I look at Corenswet and hear him speak, it allows for an incredibly welcoming presence. While this Superman is very much Corenswet’s own thing, his interpretation somewhat reminded me of what I enjoy about Christopher Reeve’s take on the character. He is a likable role model, albeit flawed in certain ways.

We learn that there is so much more to Superman behind the big fat “S.” Going back to what I said about his handling of controversy, there is a fantastic scene early on in the film where the pressures of an interview are getting to him. Lois Lane is asking him a bunch of questions and he ends up saying things that he then realizes he probably did not want to say. We see that Supes is strong on the outside, but he might not always be the best at hiding his emotions. This is not to say he is a wuss. If anything, it means he avoids falling into the trap of toxic masculinity, but he also is not afraid to showcase how he really feels.

The surprise star of the show? Krypto the Superdog. I genuinely did not expect to like this character as much as I did. First off, I am not a dog person. I am allergic to dogs and my sensitive ears are not exactly the best things to have when a dog happens to be near me and starts barking up a storm. But Krypto is perfectly utilized here. He is not exactly a “good boy.” Though I can see one making a valid argument suggesting he actually is, considering he is loyal to his master. To my surprise, Krypto’s action scenes brought out some of my biggest laughs during the film.

The thing I perhaps loved most about this movie is its nature to embrace the silly and fantastical. Of course, with this being a James Gunn film, there is a scene where Superman takes on a kaiju in the middle of Metropolis. The film skips over Superman’s origin story and introduces other DC heroes like Hawkgirl, Metamorpho, Green Lantern, and the fantastically portrayed Mr. Terrific. James Gunn knows how to inject charisma into characters who may seem like they belong in the background, and Mr. Terrific is one such example. He is most certainly as terrific as his name suggests. I almost cannot see anyone else but Edi Gathegi in his shoes. Every line out of him is given with such pizazz. I would love to have lunch with Mr. Terrific if I was given the chance.

The film kind of reminds me of a Studio Ghibli title like “Ponyo.” One of my favorite things about that film is that even the adults seem to embrace things some in “the real world” would consider to be out there or of the land of make believe. I found it fascinating how Lois Lane, who by the way is excellently portrayed by Rachel Brosnahan, simply accepts the idea that she is flying an intuitive, advanced super vehicle.

That said, with this being a comic book movie, we have the return of one of the most overused jokes in the sub-genre. Specifically, this film has a gag that has something to do with a specific name. This is a joke as common as a Dunkin’ location in New England. It is not always a bad joke, it is just overdone. This time around, it revolves around the group of heroes trying to determine what exactly to call their team. The jokes are passable and by no means offensive. But they sometimes lack originality, especially coming off of “Thunderbolts*” which handled this cliché surprisingly well.

Speaking of humor, that is something that James Gunn is no stranger to in his movies. If you are coming to “Superman” to laugh, I am not saying you won’t, but the laughs in this film are not as strong as say “Guardians of the Galaxy” or “The Suicide Squad.” Then again, laughter is not exactly the most important item on the to-do list of making a “Superman” movie. That said, it is nice to have. The script, while definitely lighthearted, sucks me in to the point where I am more excited to see Lex Luthor lose his mind.

On that note, Nicholas Hoult is irreplaceable as Lex Luthor. They say a movie is only as good as its villain. And I will remember Hoult’s interpretation of the iconic villain for a very long time. Hoult has proven himself to be a solid actor in previous projects like “The Menu” and “Juror #2.” Meanwhile in “Superman,” Hoult unleashes a side of himself I am not used to seeing. His take on Lex Luthor is almost hyperactive nightmare fuel. While Lex Luthor may look like someone who can take a punch at times, he is beyond intimidating. His methods of trying to kill Superman sometimes teeter into Saturday morning cartoon territory, but James Gunn made me buy much of the movie’s over the top tendencies and choices.

With this being the first movie of its cinematic universe, “Superman” spends a little time teasing what is ahead, and I am interested to see what is next. Of course, I am a bit predisposed to these kinds of projects, but I probably would not be as excited for what lies ahead if I was not enjoying what was already in front of me. “Superman” may not be the best movie of the year, but it is unbelievably fun. It would have been a colossal disappointment if this movie failed because you only have one chance to make a first impression. I cannot wait to see what the DCU delivers from here on out.

In the end, “Superman” is a super fun time! Is it James Gunn’s best comic book movie? No. But it is also far from his worst. It is miles better than “Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2.” “Superman” is one of the most joy-filled movies of the year. It is packed with well written, phenomenally cast characters. The film never denies that “Superman” is a godly creature, but also spends lots of time humanizing him. I loved getting to know Clark Kent, as well as his alter ego. The story may be relevant, but it is delivered in such an otherworldly vibe. I was under the impression I was watching James Gunn flip comic book pages right in front of a projector lens. While I thought the score from John Murphy and David Fleming score could have used more memorable original bits and pieces, I thought the nods to John Williams’ music added a nice touch at times. Kind of like “Jurassic World: Rebirth,” I get why Williams’ music made into the final cut. He knows how to craft an epic theme. The film is off and on in the comedy department, but when it lands, it is smooth as butter. Go see this film with a group of people, everyone is guaranteed to have a great time. I am going to give “Superman” an 8/10.

“Superman” is now playing in theaters. Tickets are available now.

Thanks for reading this review! My next review is going to be for the brand new action movie “Guns Up.” Stay tuned! Also coming soon, I will be sharing my thoughts on “The Fantastic Four: First Steps,” “The Bad Guys 2,” “Smurfs,” “Together,” and “Oh, Hi!.” If you want to see these review, and more from Scene Before, follow the blog either with an email or WordPress account! Also, check out the official Facebook page! I want to know, did you see “Superman?” What did you think about it? Or, what are some things you are looking forward to seeing in the DCU going forward? Is there anything that has not been revealed yet that you would like to see? Personally, “Peacemaker” season 2 cannot come fast enough. Let me know down below! Scene Before is your click to the flicks!