Dicks: The Musical (2023): A24’s First Musical Delivers the Goods

“Dicks: The Musical” is directed by Larry Charles (Bruno, Curb Your Enthusiasm) and stars Megan Mullally (Will & Grace, Bob’s Burgers), Megan Thee Stallion (She-Hulk: Attorney at Law, Legendary), Bowen Yang (Saturday Night Live, Awkwafina is Nora from Queens), Nathan Lane (The Lion King, Stuart Little), Aaron Jackson (The Chris Gethard Show: Public Access, National Lampoon Radio Hour), and Josh Sharp (Jared & Ivanka, Search Party). This film is based on an off-Broadway musical titled “F*cking Identical Twins” and is about two business rivals who come to realization that they are long lost twin brothers. In an attempt to bring their divorced parents back together, they decide to swap places and disguise themselves as the other.

I have been curious about “Dicks: The Musical” ever since I first watched the trailer in August. I am not the biggest musical guy, but I have long been an A24 guy. They are not always consistent in quality, but that is a part of the young distributor’s charm. They always distribute content that has an identity of its own and would tend to carry certain notable qualities about it. Even when I end up hating a film of theirs like “Zola” or “The Whale,” there is still a specialty to those pictures. They always feel distinguished, individualistic, and polished no matter the budget.

In the case of “Dicks: The Musical,” the budget is $12 million. Not the most expensive movie, but it is one that uses its money wisely. Because every frame is packed with joyous splendor. From start to finish, I had a ball of a time with “Dicks: The Musical.” What sells the movie hardest is its marvelous cast who just so happen to play each role to the best of their ability, all to the point where I cannot imagine anybody else in their shoes. This is a film that refuses to take itself seriously. On it’s surface, this movie is like “The Parent Trap,” but different. In terms of recent movies, “Dicks: The Musical” kind of reminded me of “Bottoms,” because it is set in a universe that packs in various similarities to our own, but it is also one that feels like an enhancement of everyday life. Granted, it is a musical, which is not the most everyday feeling genre, so it only makes sense. And thankfully, as a musical, this movie works perfectly. All the songs are properly placed, well choreographed, well sung, and make sense within the context of the story. I am not going to pretend I am going to buy the soundtrack for this film, but the music accompanies everything else the film has to offer nicely.

That said, again, the film is budgeted at $12 million. When compared to recent musicals like “La La Land,” “Tick, Tick…BOOM!,” and Steven Spielberg’s “West Side Story” adaptation, it is significantly cheap. Despite my comments for the choreography and the songs, the budget does show at times when you consider everything put on screen. There may be occasional extravagance here and there, but that comes with infinite camp. Within all the pizzazz, there is a continued slight sense of humility.

The lead twins are played by Aaron Jackson and Josh Sharp. I have not known these names by any chance, but this movie could put them on the map. At least for me. Because it took me a bit to find out that not only is this movie based on something else… That something else just so happens to be a play in which they created and starred. Both of these men are stacked with talent and make for a perfect pair. I buy them as rivals, and I also buy them as brothers. I know this is probably a weird comparison to make, but they kind of remind me of the Smosh duo. Anthony Padilla and Ian Hecox. Their chemistry is always on point and they both consistently deliver high energy in addition to humor.

My favorite characters of the film have to be the twins’ parents. They have the best lines, the best quirks, the best backstories, and on top of that, their costumes and looks match the feel of the film. They look just as kooky as the vibe of this picture. They look like they fit the style and match the attire of a higher-up at Willy Wonka’s chocolate factory. The parents outfits pop just as much as their voices. Both talking and singing for that matter. I did not expect to be as invested in this film’s plot as I turned out to be. When a particular bombshell is revealed about Evelyn (Mullally) early on in the film, I was very curious as to where things would go from here. I was kind of expecting the big obstacle of the movie to be that these two people don’t really feel anything for each other the way they once did. While that idea is noticeable throughout the script, there is more to their disconnect than meets the eye. And some of it, particularly regarding Evelyn’s bombshell, is wonderfully ridiculous.

My biggest surprise of the film would have to be Megan Thee Stallion. I thought she was really good here. I don’t listen to her music, though I have heard her sing before on “Saturday Night Live,” I thought she stood out. And while “Dicks: The Musical” is not her first acting gig, she is not the first person I would think of casting in a film if I were to make one. I did see her guest appearance in “She-Hulk: Attorney at Law” as herself, but even with her limited role, I thought she was a tad stiff. To my pleasant surprise, she is a lot better here. I do not know what her future is as an actor, though I do see she has an upcoming film with Adam Sandler and the Safdie Brothers in the works. That said, I thought she was a fine choice to play the character of Gloria. She is dynamic, has tons of personality, and of course, because it is a musical, she has a chance to unleash a proper singing voice.

I do not know when would be the next time I would plan on sitting down and watching “Dicks: The Musical.” I have seen much better entries to this genre that have more replay value. Heck, going back to Steven Spielberg’s “West Side Story,” I ended up seeing it twice in theaters and I also rewatched it on 4K Blu-ray. If I had any other gripes with the film, it would be that the comedy, while funny, never reaches a level where I am rolling on the floor. It is worthy of chuckles, but maybe not death-inducing laughter. Even so, I found the movie to be funny. I found it to be joy-filled. I found it to have a ton of character. It has the vivid nature of a Wes Anderson movie with the ridiculousness of, apologies if this is too recent, but I think it is a fine example, “Bottoms.” It is energetic, fast, and delivers a happy go lucky, stupid good time.

In the end, “Dicks: The Musical” gets my recommendation if you are looking for something quick and fun to watch. And I do mean it, the movie is quick. Not only is it tightly paced, but the runtime is 86 minutes. If you want to watch something neat without having to kill a ton of time, “Dicks: The Musical” is a nice choice. I have seen better comedies. I have seen better musicals. But even so, “Dicks: The Musical” handles both genres respectably. This is A24’s first musical, and I doubt it is their last. And if it is not their last, I doubt this is their best. But if you make the choice to check it out, you are not doing yourself any disservice. It is a good movie, give it a watch sometime. I am going to give “Dicks: The Musical” a 7/10.

“Dicks: The Musical” is now playing in theaters. Tickets are available now.

Thanks for reading this review! If you enjoyed this review, good news! There are plenty more where that came from! If you missed out on my Ridley Scottober event, you are in luck! Because if you click any of the following links, you can check out my reviews for “Body of Lies,” “Gladiator,” “All the Money in the World,” and “Blade Runner!” Check them out! My next review is going to be for Martin Scorsese’s latest piece of cinema, “Killers of the Flower Moon!” Also coming soon, I will be sharing my thoughts on “Freelance,” “The Persian Version,” “Priscilla,” and “The Tunnel to Summer, the Exit of Goodbyes!” If you want to see these reviews and more from Scene Before, follow the blog either with an email or WordPress account! Also, check out the official Facebook page! I want to know, did you see “Dicks: The Musical?” What did you think about it? Or, what is your favorite A24 film? At the risk of sounding too mainstream, I gotta go with “Everything Everywhere All at Once.” Let me know down your picks down below! Scene Before is your click to the flicks!

Leave a comment