“Exit 8” is directed by Genki Kawamura (A Hundred Flowers, Duality) and stars Kazunari Ninomiya (Letters from Iwo Jima, Assassination Classroom), Yamato Kochi (Vivant, Brothers in Arms), Naru Asanuma (A Calm Sea and Beautiful Days with You, The Night After the Divorce), Kotone Hanase (Suzume, The Parades), and Nana Komatsu (Silence, The World of Kanako). This film follows a man who finds himself trapped in a subway station and must complete a puzzling mission in order to escape.

Turns out “The Super Mario Galaxy Movie” is not the only film coming out in April that is based on a video game, because “Exit 8” just so happens to originate from the same medium. The two games, and by extension, films, are quite different. “Mario” is much more family-friendly and adventurous, while “Exit 8” takes a more intimate and scarier route. The differences also happen to extend to my relationship with the games. While I have played many of “Mario’s” titles from different eras, I have not once sat down and played “The Exit 8.” To be fair though, the game is a somewhat recent indie title and way less popular than “Mario.”

Although my ability to enjoy a film should not be factored by how popular or recognizable the concept happens to be. As a wise woman from an ESurance commercial once said, “That’s not how it works. That’s not how any of this works.” Speaking of not working, I wish that were not the case for this movie, because it is one of the biggest bores I have seen all year.

I am not going to deny that “Exit 8” has potential. In fact, once I heard the concept, it gave me a weird sense of nostalgia. I am at the point now that I drive to work, partially due to the public transit in Boston not running overnight. But when I was in college, I took public transit everywhere, including the subway. As someone who has taken the subway so frequently, I appreciate the filmmakers’ intentions to make the concept scary. Because when I was taking it in Boston, it sometimes was. You are riding a germ-infested car with a bunch of strangers that sometimes squeaks like there is no tomorrow. Shoutout to the Green Line for reminding me of why I hate having sensitive ears, especially when it stops at Boylston and Government Center.

This movie, to my lack of surprise, dives into some common annoyances of riding the subway. The crowds… The occasional lack of cell service… The noise… The film starts in a clever way by showing the world through the protagonist’s eyes and ears. We see him riding the subway, and when he has his headphones off, he hears a baby crying, he does nothing about it. Though someone else, who is fed up with the noise, is telling the mother how annoyed he is. Of course, there is nothing the baby can do about it, and the mother, who has way more tact than she should, apologizes to the irritated rider.

The movie sometimes succeeds when it comes to atmosphere. The subway, despite extending quite far, does feel kind of otherworldly between the loud trains, strange halls, and depending on the case, large crowds. This movie occasionally goes beyond the everyday eeriness of the subway by implementing unusual characters, chilling sound effects, and some occasionally spooky effects. There is one moment involving eyes on posters that I will remember for some time.

That said, this movie becomes dull very easily. In a way, I almost felt as trapped as this film’s own protagonist. The film does a good job at showing how much the protagonist learns in a specific period of time, but it does not change the fact that the film feels as repetitive as can be. I think this could have been paced a lot better as a short film rather than a feature. There is a decent movie in here somewhere between the suspense and immersion factors, but very rarely did I find the story intriguing or the scares all that horrifying. When I watch a horror movie and I am not scared, that is a problem.

In fact, after watching this movie, I was searching its Wikipedia page, and I found out that the director, Genki Kawamura, ended up cutting a scene that he deemed too scary to show. I really want to see that scene now. At best, this movie is mildly eerie, but I cannot name a single moment during the runtime that had me pacing a just a little. I hate saying this, especially as someone who has taken the subway on a regular basis, so I have come across my share of interesting characters and sights. Although the more I think about it, I wonder if that is part of why I am not so scared by this movie. I have taken the subway so regularly back in the day, and I still take it sometimes today, to the point where what could have once been strange is now familiar or expected.

Granted, while this film does ground itself when it comes to showcasing the horrors of the subway, it also tries to blend in some more fantastical elements as well. I am not saying those could not have worked, but I do wish they were improved.

Also, I have no idea how many other people are going to complain about this, but the dialogue in this film irked me. I could only hear The Lost Man (Ninomaya) repeat the same things over and over so many times. I get that repeating his words is perhaps his way of understanding his surroundings, but as a viewer, it only makes every scene featuring said character feel almost the same as the last. If there is any variety to be found, it feels scarce. I found myself surprisingly frustrated with this character’s progression as he tries to escape.

“Exit 8” is kind of like “Groundhog Day” or “Edge of Tomorrow” as we constantly see the Lost Man doing the same things over and over and trying to complete a major task in the process. Maybe the movie was trying its best to suck me into the atmosphere of the subway, but if anything I found myself more annoyed that I had to go through various parts of the movie in real time. Or in this movie’s case, as real as time can be in its specific context. On the other hand, “Edge of Tomorrow” will sometimes trim out the fat while not removing anything essential from the story. If I found “Exit 8’s” short list of characters more intriguing, this would be moot. But I did not, so here I am, complaining like a madman. I wish I cared more about the Lost Man’s personal dilemma regarding his love interest. I wish I cared more about the Boy. I wish I cared more about everyone in this movie. Unfortunately, however, I cared so little to the point where I cannot see myself watching this movie ever again.

In the end, I am surprised to say this… If I were to recommend a video game-based movie to watch in theaters right now, I would shockingly pick “The Super Mario Galaxy Movie.” Yes, I have complaints with the movie, but I feel like it did a slightly better job at accomplishing its goals, even with a lack of story. “Exit 8” has a story, but I cannot say it is the best story. Despite being a horror flick, I found nothing about it that scary. I did find it atmospheric. It did remind me of times when I would walk through long subway tunnels or find myself in a sea of people on the Orange Line riding through Boston. The acting is not bad either. I have no problem with the cast, but I wish they were given superior material to work with. I am probably in the minority when it comes to my opinion. Both critics and audiences seem to be raving about the film over on Rotten Tomatoes. This film is not a complete trainwreck, but if I were ever presented with the opportunity to watch “Exit 8” a second time, I could see myself going to the next stop. I am going to give “Exit 8” a 4/10.

“Exit 8” is now playing in theaters. Tickets are available now.

Thanks for reading this review! Special reminder that my next episode of Movie Requests drops Monday, May 4th! That is Star Wars Day! Therefore, it is only fitting that Katee Sackhoff, known for her work as Bo-Katan Kryze, will end up being the guest of the next episode! You can catch the episode here on Flicknerd.com, or you can subscribe to my YouTube channel to see it as soon as possible!

And if you want to check out my last episode of Movie Requests featuring “Avatar” actor Joel David Moore, you can click the link above and watch it for yourself. If you enjoy the video, leave a like! It helps me out!

My next review is going to be for “Normal.” Stay tuned! Also coming soon, I will be sharing my thoughts on “Lorne” and “Michael,” which sounds like a gigantic missed opportunity to form the next “Barbenheimer.” LORNE MICHAEL! Come on, guys! If you want to see these reviews and more from Scene Before, follow the blog either with an email or WordPress account! Also, check out the official Facebook page! I want to know, did you see “Exit 8?” What did you think about it? Or, what is your favorite movie involving trains? If it is not “Spider-Man 2,” we need to talk. Let me know down below! Scene Before is your click to the flicks!